Retirement Plans

Reframing ESG for ERISA fiduciaries

We explain how the final version of the DOL’s ESG rule changes the landscape for ERISA fiduciaries.

For information on Retirement Plan Services, please visit our website.

The US Department of Labor (the “DOL”) released a final rule on November 22, 2022 addressing the circumstances under which fiduciaries of plans governed by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, as amended (“ERISA”) may consider environmental, social and governance (“ESG”) factors when making investment decisions. The final rule also addresses fiduciary responsibilities with respect to proxy voting and other shareholder rights. While the rule generally will be effective on January 30, 2023, some of the proxy voting provisions will not take effect until December 1, 2023.

The new rule, entitled Prudence and Loyalty in Selecting Plan Investments and Exercising Shareholder Rights (the “Final Rule”), clarifies the role ESG factors may play within the traditional investment decision-making framework set out in ERISA. The Final Rule supports the conclusion that ESG factors may be economically material to an investment’s financial performance and recognizes that ESG factors can, in some circumstances, be just as relevant to an investment decision as more traditional financial and accounting factors. It de-emphasizes prior guidance’s focus on ESG and provides a broad gloss on fiduciary investment decision-making in general.

The Final Rule is a sharp about-face from prior DOL guidance published in 2020 (the “2020 Rule”). While the 2020 Rule did not explicitly ban ERISA-regulated fiduciaries from considering ESG factors, it cautioned fiduciaries against ESG funds, warning they should not “too hastily conclude that ESG funds may be selected …”

The 2020 Rule also imposed procedural requirements and additional restrictions for defined contribution plans that permit participant-directed investments. Many ERISA plan fiduciaries were concerned that this framework created significant additional risk of ERISA fiduciary liability if a fiduciary were to consider ESG factors, even where such factors were financially relevant.

Below we highlight three key changes instituted by the Final Rule:

1. Clarifies that ERISA-regulated fiduciaries may consider ESG factors that are relevant to an investment’s expected financial performance.

While the Final Rule is much more supportive of ESG than the 2020 Rule, the Final Rule does not mandate that ERISA fiduciaries must consider ESG factors. Rather, ESG factors can take their place among the myriad of financially relevant factors that fiduciaries may consider when making investment decisions on behalf of the plan, without any required additional documentation or justification.

In the preamble to the Final Rule, the DOL describes its concern that “the current regulation [the 2020 Rule] created a perception that fiduciaries are at risk if they include any ESG factors in the financial evaluation of plan investments.” At the same time, the DOL walked back language it had proposed implying that ESG factors must be considered in certain circumstances, stating it never intended to “improperly place a thumb on the scale in favor of ESG investing.”

2. Allows for consideration of participant preference, in certain circumstances.

The Final Rule adds a new provision stating that a fiduciary of a participant-directed individual account plan does not violate its duty of loyalty simply by taking participant preference into account, as long as it does so in a manner consistent with the requirements of the duties of loyalty and prudence. This new provision appears to be driven by comments regarding the impact of participant preference on participation in defined contribution plans. The preamble states that “if accommodating participants’ preferences will lead to greater participation and higher deferral rates, then it could lead to greater retirement security.”

The DOL notes that this position is not novel, but rather is intended to provide clarity on a position the DOL described when adopting the 2020 Rule.

3. Eases consideration of “collateral benefits” by changing the standard for the “tie-breaker.”

DOL guidance on “social” or “economically targeted” investing has long included a “tie-breaker test,” whereby a fiduciary could consider collateral, or non-financial, factors to “break the tie” between investment options that are otherwise identical from a risk-return perspective. The 2020 Rule stated that a fiduciary could consider collateral benefits, including ESG factors, to distinguish only between otherwise “economically indistinguishable” investments, although such situations were seen to be unlikely. If a fiduciary did rely on the tie-breaker exception to consider collateral benefits, the 2020 Rule imposed specific documentation requirements.

The Final Rule changes the standard from “economically indistinguishable” to instances where “competing investments… equally serve the financial interests of the plan” and removes the documentation requirements. In the preamble, the DOL referenced comments stating that the 2020 Rule’s version of the tie-breaker singled out certain factors over other factors, “contrary to the principles of neutrality.” Notably, the DOL’s discussion in the preamble de-emphasizes ESG, listing several more general examples of possible collateral benefits.

In sum, the Final Rule imposes a significant change on the regulatory context surrounding ESG investing with ERISA plan assets. It also provides a broader look at what factors, in addition to ESG, an ERISA-regulated fiduciary may consider. Fiduciaries interested in these issues may wish to consult with consultants, attorneys and/or industry organizations on whether or how to adjust their fiduciary decision-making processes going forward.

Distributed by UBS Financial Services Inc. in collaboration with Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP.

For information on Retirement Plan Services, please visit our website.


Source: Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP (2022) © Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP. All rights reserved. Used with permission.

Disclaimers:

This material has been prepared by Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP, an international law firm with one of the largest Employee Benefits and Executive Compensation practices in the country. The information contained in this material is provided as a general informational service. It should not be construed as, and does not constitute, legal advice on any specific matter, nor does this message create an attorney-client relationship.

This publication is provided by UBS Financial Services Inc. and includes content provided by Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP.  UBS Financial Services Inc. has not verified the accuracy or completeness of such information. This publication is provided for informational purposes only, contains a brief summary of the topic discussed and does not represent a comprehensive discussion or list of questions or considerations necessary for making effective decisions. You should seek appropriate professional advice regarding the matters discussed in this publication in light of your specific situation. Neither UBS Financial Services Inc. nor any of its employees provide tax or legal advice. You should consult with your legal and/or tax advisors and the provider of your plan administration services regarding your retirement plan.

UBS Financial Services Inc., its affiliates and its employees are not in the business of providing tax or legal advice. Clients should seek advice based on their particular circumstances from an independent tax or legal advisor.

Important information about brokerage and advisory services.
As a firm providing wealth management services to clients, UBS Financial Services Inc. offers investment advisory services in its capacity as an SEC-registered investment adviser and brokerage services in its capacity as an SEC-registered broker-dealer. Investment advisory services and brokerage services are separate and distinct, differ in material ways and are governed by different laws and separate arrangements. It is important that you understand the ways in which we conduct business, and that you carefully read the agreements and disclosures that we provide to you about the products or services we offer. For more information, please review the client relationship summary provided at ubs.com/relationshipsummary, or ask your UBS Financial Advisor for a copy.

For plan sponsor use only—not for participant distribution.

© UBS 2022. All rights reserved. The key symbol and UBS are among the registered and unregistered trademarks of UBS. UBS Financial Services Inc. is a subsidiary of UBS AG. Member FINRA/SIPC.
UBS Financial Services Inc.
ubs.com/fs
2022-739100
Expiration: 12/31/23 Review Code: IS2206874