Fixed income investing Big Bang and Big Crunch: space theories and global debt
Look up into the night sky and the space between the stars and planets appears completely dark. But view that same sky through a radio telescope and instead see a pale background glow that fills your view. What you are seeing is in fact faint background radiation or the so-called Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB), filling all space. The discovery of this leftover, or remnant, radiation in 1964 was crucial evidence for the 'Big Bang' creation of the universe. The Big Bang theory itself was partially derived from the discovery that the farther away galaxies are, the faster they are moving away from the earth. Imagining this cosmic expansion running backwards in time leads to the dense and hot very early universe that is the plausible source of the CMB.
Just as the Big Bang theory is a credible hypothesis for the start of the universe – the 'Big Crunch' is the symmetric view of its ultimate fate; the density of the universe is enough to ultimately stop its expansion, triggering a collapse right back to a dimensionless 'singularity' where space and time have no meaning1.
For better or for worse, markets too go through their own versions of the 'Big Bang' and 'Big Crunch' with a profound impact on asset returns. Successful investing is, in part, about forming views around plausible versions of the future, based on observable data today.
We certainly have our own expanding galaxy of debt on which to hypothesize. Chart 1 shows that debt levels globally hit a record high of USD 258 trillion (or 331% of global GDP) in Q1 2020.
Global debt is now >300% of GDP
Chart 1 – Global debt from 2011 to 2020
Clearly, the impact of COVID-19 and the early fiscal response have had a big effect, and all the subsequent data shows this pace has accelerated since then. But the chart reveals that the trend was already well established. Debt levels have been going up and up over time.
What is also apparent is that total debt is increasing at a faster rate than growth in the global economy, so overall leverage (in this case debt relative to global output) is increasing. For a long time now, adding debt to the global economy has not been of obvious benefit to the overall growth rate.
Fixed income investing More debt can be a drag on growth
Part of the reason is simply that, all else being equal, more debt means more spent on debt service, which itself can be a drag on growth. Certainly higher overall systemic leverage has been a factor in central banks' need to keep policy rates low. Chart 2 shows the path of the US Federal Reserve's target rate over time. It is noticeable that, as global debt levels have risen, not only is the overall trend sharply lower, but each peak in rates is lower than the last.
Chart 2 – Federal Funds Target Rate 1984 to 2020
Policy rates are the 'background radiation' that permeate the pricing of every asset class. As a consequence, exactly the same effects are observable in broader bond market yields. Chart 3 shows the yield on the Global Aggregate Bond Index (a very broad global bond universe tracked by many investors) which twenty years ago yielded nearly 5.6% but at the beginning of August this year reached a record low of just 0.8%.
Fixed income investing Falling yield has important implications for future returns
This falling yield has very important implications for future returns. Between 2000 and the end of July 2020 the Global Aggregate Bond Index produced an annual average total return of 4.6%2. Almost 85% of this return came from income (remember, the starting yield was about 5.6%). Now think again about that 0.8% yield on the bond universe today. We can see that the prospect for future broad-market bond returns over the next twenty years seems rather lower than the past twenty.
Chart 3 – Global aggregate bond yield 2000 to 2020
Fixed income investing Low yields will not reverse soon
That said, it seems extremely unlikely that the trend in yields will reverse anytime soon. As I have written recently on previous Bond Bites publications, many governments need rates to stay low if the positive impact of the massive fiscal expansion is not to be eroded; and central banks are more than willing to assist via asset purchases and policy rates nailed to the floor.
The key point for bond investors today is that, while overall broad market returns are likely to be lower than in the past, different sectors of the market will offer quite different risk-reward characteristics over time.
So the diminishing prospective return of a passive allocation to the broad-market should alert investors to the need for active styles that embrace the widest possible opportunity set.
What outcomes might today's world of low growth, high debt and low yields foreshadow? Very broadly at least three paths seem conceivable;
Fixed income investing 3 outcomes from low growth, high debt and low yields world
1. Debt deflation spiral
It could end in the 'Big Crunch'; today's very low levels of growth, but coupled with ever more borrowing, eventually ends in a debt deflation spiral. Low inflation or even deflation leads to high real costs of debt servicing causing companies and consumers to default on loans and mortgages which have become too large to manage. This in turn leads to pressure on the banking sector, leading to less lending and more insolvency in a downward spiral. In this environment cash and high quality government bonds probably outperform credit.
2. Big Bang in inflation
On the other hand, a continued expansion of government spending might lead to a 'Big Bang' in inflation which destroys the value of debt in real terms but crushes the value of savings with it. This scenario isn't likely over at least the next year or so as the deflationary effects of COVID-19 predominate. It will become a much bigger risk if capacity constraints arise in economies where massive fiscal spending creates excess demand that ultimately forces up prices. Inflation protected securities could do relatively well here.
3. Real growth rates and inflation go up
Alternatively, we could see the policy-makers preferred 'steady state' outcome. Here the trends of the past 30 years go into reverse; global growth rates exceed the rate of expansion of global debt, real growth rates accelerate and inflation goes up – but not too much. It's perfectly possible, but it would mark a break in some very well established trends. That said, credit and emerging market bonds would be likely winners.
As momentous as it will be, our best estimates for the end of the universe still place it billions of years away.
The end of the bond bull market is probably rather nearer, even though today it might seem as enduring as time itself. Exactly how and when it will unfold is still extremely uncertain. So investors should critically appraise their bond holdings now to ensure they have the diversification and flexibility to thrive in what will be a very challenging world!